Retrofit or replace? Making the right call on an ageing leak testing system

Retrofit or replace your leak testing system?

Every leak testing system eventually forces a decision. The machine still runs, but spare parts take longer to source, a new product variant is on its way, or the control system cannot exchange data with the plant's MES. At that point, someone has to choose between upgrading the existing system and buying a new one.

Retrofitting means modernising an installed machine. Some modules are replaced, new functions are added, or the system is adapted to a new product, and the parts with useful life left in them stay in service. At MVS Technologies, we retrofit our own systems as well as machines built by other manufacturers.

That work has taught us that modifying an existing machine is harder engineering than building a new one, because every decision is bound by what is already there. When a retrofit is not the right answer, we say so openly. This article explains how we tell the difference, component by component.

The vacuum chamber moves more than you think

Most people picture the vacuum chamber as the fixed backbone of a leak tester. It actually flexes all the time. Each cycle evacuates the chamber and vents it back to atmosphere, and with every cycle the walls deflect inwards and spring back. Depending on the design, the movement may be a few millimetres or a few tenths of one. Over years of production, it adds up.

Metal fatigue is the reason this matters. In an article on pressure vessel fatigue, the National Board of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors points out that the number of stress repetitions counts for more than time in service. A crack, once started, grows slightly with each cycle. The article also warns that nobody can predict the exact end of a vessel's life with certainty, and that failure can arrive as a slow leak or as something far more sudden.

In a vacuum chamber, microcracks form where stress concentrates, usually around welds and changes in geometry. Repairing a cracked chamber reliably is difficult, and keeping it in service is unsafe. Swapping it out also takes time. Even with a spare chamber already on site, experienced technicians need several days in the best case.

The National Board's inspection guidance points the same way. It calls for a thorough examination at roughly half the predicted life and, closer to the end, non-destructive testing aimed specifically at cracks in highly stressed areas. Inspection is part of a plan, and that plan finishes in one of two places: replacement, or a documented decision to extend the service life.

We raise this at the start of every retrofit project. Technically, the original chamber can stay in a modernised machine. On a system with more than ten years of operation behind it, though, upgrading everything around that chamber is rarely a sound decision. Our advice is to respect the lifetime the chamber supplier specifies and to plan the replacement before the chamber makes that decision for you.

Pumps and electrical cabinets age differently

Vacuum pumps follow another logic. A well-maintained pump that still delivers its rated performance can stay in service at 15 years old, as long as a spare unit sits on the shelf. At that age, it is close to the end of its expected life and could fail any day. When it does, the replacement goes in within a few hours and production restarts. That short recovery time is what makes the risk acceptable, and the chamber simply cannot offer it.

With the electrical cabinet, the problem after ten years or more is rarely wear. Components go out of production, and a failed part can no longer be swapped like for like. The Siemens SIMATIC S7-300, one of the most widely used PLC families in machine building, shows how the timeline typically runs. Siemens introduced it in 1994 and moved it into phase-out in October 2023. Since October 2025, new modules can no longer be ordered from Siemens, while spare parts and support are guaranteed until around 2033. According to the same source, the platform was still in wide industrial use in 2025.

If the pumping station is sound and its spare parts are secured, we regard replacing the electrical cabinet as a fully valid retrofit. The machine gets a new control platform and new software, and often gains a capability it never had before: integration with the plant's MES.

When a retrofit is the right call

Retrofit projects vary enormously in scope. A contained job might mean a new electrical cabinet with new control software, or a fresh set of tooling. At the far end, the work amounts to a new machine that reuses selected parts of the old one, usually the frame and a pumping station that still performs.

In our experience, a retrofit makes strong sense in these top four situations:

Obsolete controls on sound mechanics.

The cabinet and software are outdated, yet the pumps and chamber are within their service life, and spare parts are still available. 

A new product on an existing line.

The new variant needs different tooling, or a new chamber if the part no longer fits the old one.

Missing connectivity

The plant wants MES integration, data logging or traceability, and the original control system cannot provide it.

Helium consumption. 

A standalone Helium Recovery Unit connects to existing machines by piping, and our units reclaim up to 95% of the helium used in testing. Since the 2026 helium supply disruption, this has become one of the most practical upgrades available to a plant.


Modular design makes several of these steps much simpler. We build our own systems in modules for exactly this reason: when the time comes, a chamber or a complete functional unit can be exchanged without rebuilding the machine around it. With equipment from other manufacturers, the room for manoeuvre depends on how the original machine was designed. That is why each of those projects begins with a thorough assessment.

When replacement is the better answer

A tighter test specification is the clearest signal for replacement. Customers raise their requirements, new product generations arrive with lower acceptable leak rates, and regulation adds pressure of its own. The EU's revised F-gas Regulation (EU) 2024/573, in force since March 2024, keeps emission prevention and leak checks at the centre of its containment rules for equipment that carries refrigerant.

A machine built for yesterday's specification can hit its limits in one place or in several at once. Its leak detector may lack the sensitivity the new limit demands. An ageing chamber may carry a background level that leaves too little margin below the reject threshold. Sometimes the existing pumping configuration simply cannot reach the required cycle time. Which constraint applies depends on the task, and a proper assessment will show you which one you are facing.

The shape of the retrofit itself is the second signal. Imagine the assessment finds the chamber at the end of its life, the controls obsolete and the tooling due for change. You are then looking at a new machine in all but name, and in that case we recommend an honest comparison with a new system designed around the current specification from day one.

What a sound retrofit requires

Every retrofit we take on begins with an assessment, and on machines from other manufacturers this step carries even more weight. Our team inspects the system on site, reviews the available documentation and drawings, and establishes which components still have reliable life in them. The result is a clear scope that also names the parts which should not stay in service.

Two further conditions decide whether the modernised machine will run reliably. The first is expertise. Modifying an existing design leaves far less freedom than starting from a blank sheet, so the work calls for people who understand vacuum systems and leak testing in depth. Spare parts are the second. A retrofitted machine that keeps older components in service can only be as dependable as the stock behind them, as the pump example shows.

MVS Technologies provides a warranty on the work carried out during a retrofit, so responsibility for what has been changed is clear from the day the machine returns to production.

Start with an honest assessment

There is rarely a universal answer to retrofit or replace. The right decision depends on the condition of each component and on the specification the machine must meet over the coming years, weighed against the downtime the plant can afford. We will tell you when a retrofit makes sense, and just as plainly when it would only postpone a bigger problem.

A few questions give you a useful starting point. How old is the vacuum chamber, and what lifetime did its supplier specify? Can you still get spare parts for the control system, and until when? Will the test specification tighten before the machine reaches the end of its planned service life? Answer those, and the right path usually becomes clear quickly.

If you operate an ageing leak testing system, whether we built it or another manufacturer did, get in touch with MVS Technologies. A condition assessment is the first step towards a decision you will not have to revisit in two years' time.

Related posts